Divorce and Legal Separation
in Colorado
Colorado
is a no fault state as far as the grounds for divorce (dissolution
of marriage) are concerned. Many years ago, one had to prove a basis
for a divorce, such as adultery, physical cruelty, abandonment, etc.
Today, all the court must find for a party to be granted a divorce
are the following: (1) one of the parties has lived in Colorado for
90 days immediately preceding the commencement of the divorce
proceeding, (2) the marriage is irretrievably broken with no
reasonable chance of reconciliation, and (3) 90 days or more have
passed since the court acquired jurisdiction over both parties.
Generally, the issues involved in a divorce will include some, or
all, of the following: (1) the amount of alimony (now called
maintenance), if any, to be awarded to one of the parties, (2) the
amount of child support, if any, to be awarded to either or both of
the parents, (3) parental responsibility allocation for the children
including issues of education, religious upbringing, visitation, and
vacations with children, (4) amount of attorney and expert witness
fees, if any, to be paid for the benefit of one spouse by the other,
where one spouse makes substantially more money than the other, and
(5) allocation of assets and liabilities between the parties.
All of the items noted also apply to an order (decree) of legal
separation. Oftentimes, a decree of legal separation is sought for
religious reasons where a particular religion does not authorize or
recognize divorce.
When filing a petition for divorce or legal separation, the filing
party has a duty to disclose to the court the conditions of any
prior temporary or permanent restraining orders and civil protection
orders to prevent domestic abuse, as well as any emergency
protection orders entered against either party by any court within
two years prior to the filing of the divorce petition or petition
for legal separation.
If both of the parties, by petition or otherwise, have stated under
oath that the marriage is irretrievably broken, or one of the
parties has so stated and the other has not denied it, there is a
presumption that such is the case. Unless controverted by evidence,
the court is required, at the hearing, to make a finding that the
marriage is irretrievably broken. If one party has denied, under
oath, that the marriage is irretrievably broken, the court will
consider all relevant factors, including the circumstances that gave
rise to the filing of the divorce petition, as well as the prospect
of reconciliation, and will: (1) make a finding whether the marriage
is irretrievably broken, or (2) continue the matter for a further
hearing not less than 30 days, or more than 60 days later, or as
soon thereafter as the matter can be set on the court's calendar,
and may suggest to the parties that they seek counseling. It is
extremely rare that one party will claim the marriage is not
irretrievably broken when the other party has so claimed. It would
be even rarer that the court will engage in hearings associated with
this issue. Rather, the courts in Colorado almost universally accept
the filing party's position that the marriage is irretrievably
broken.
A marriage can be declared invalid if entered into under the
following circumstances: (1) a party lacked the capacity to consent
to the marriage at the time the marriage was finalized, either
because of mental incapacity or infirmity, or because of the
influence of alcohol, drugs, or other incapacitating circumstances,
(2) a party lacked the physical capacity to consummate the marriage
by sexual intercourse and the other party did not know at the time
of the marriage of this problem, (3) a party was under the age
provided by law and did not have parental or guardian consent, or
judicial approval, as provided by law, (4) one party entered into
the marriage in reliance upon a fraudulent act or representation of
the other party, which fraudulent act or representation goes to the
essence of the marriage, (5) one or both of the parties entered into
the marriage under duress, (6) one or both of the parties entered
into the marriage as a joke or dare, or (7) the marriage was
prohibited by law, reasons for which would include: (a) the marriage
was entered into prior to the dissolution of an earlier marriage,
(b) the marriage was between an ancestor and antecedent, or between
a brother and a sister, or (c) the marriage was between an uncle and
a niece, or between an aunt and a nephew, or (8) the marriage was
void by the law of the place where the marriage was contracted.
Parties are permitted to enter into an agreement (called a a
Separation Agreement) to deal with the disposition of their
property, allocation of parental responsibilities, support, and
parenting time, and to deal with issues of alimony (maintenance).
However, the court is required to review a Separation Agreement and
make a finding that the same is not unconscionable. If the parties
do not enter into a Separation Agreement to be presented to the
court in conjunction with the court signing a decree of dissolution
(divorce), there will be a trial of any issues which the parties
have not agreed upon. This trial is called a permanent orders
hearing and is subject to most of the rules associated with any
other civil trial. However, there is no right to a jury associated
with divorce cases. All divorce cases are tried before a judge.
As a general statement, all monies and property acquired during the
marriage are considered marital property. However, there are three
categories of property which would be considered by the court to be
separate property. The three categories are: (1) any gift received
by either spouse during the marriage to him or her alone is
considered to be his or her separate property, (2) any property
either spouse receives by way of inheritance to him or her alone
will be considered his or her separate property, and (3) any
property brought into the marriage by either spouse and maintained
as his or her separate property during the marriage retains that
characteristic. To the extent, however, any gift, inheritance, or
property brought into the marriage appreciates during the marriage,
the appreciated amount would be considered marital property.
Colorado is not a community property state. There is no law which
requires the judge to split the assets equally between the parties
or to provide "x" amount of property, dollar-wise or percentage-wise,
to either spouse. Rather, Colorado is an equity state. This means
the court will allocate the property between the parties based on
what the court thinks is fair. With regard to alimony (maintenance),
there is a statute which provides that when maintenance is required
by a party, and when the combined annual gross income of the two
parties is $75,000 or less, there is a rebuttable presumption in
favor of the specific award of temporary maintenance from the higher
income party to the lower income party based on a formula. If the
combined income of the parties exceeds $75,000, there is no formula
to be applied related to maintenance. Rather, it is the court which
determines the amount of temporary and permanent maintenance.
The court, in determining maintenance, includes the following
considerations in reaching a decision: (1) the financial resources
of a party seeking maintenance, including marital property
apportioned to such party and the party's ability to meet his or her
needs independently, including the extent to which a provision for
support of a child living with the party includes a sum for that
party, (b) the time necessary to acquire sufficient education or
training to enable the party seeking maintenance to find appropriate
employment and that party's future earning capacity, (c) the
standard of living established during the marriage, (d) the duration
of the marriage, (e) the age and the physical and emotional
condition of the party seeking maintenance, and (f) the ability of
the spouse from whom maintenance is sought to meet his or her needs
while meeting those needs of the spouse seeking maintenance.
Maintenance generally is awarded by a court until such time as
either party dies or the spouse receiving the maintenance remarries.
Maintenance amounts received by a party are taxable to him or her,
while the party paying maintenance is allowed to deduct the amount
of the maintenance payment on his or her tax forms.
The parties can agree to what is called a contractual maintenance.
This means the parties can contract that one party will pay the
other party "x" amount of
money for "y" amount of time regardless of remarriage;
however, the amount and duration of payment is non-modifiable. A
court cannot order contractual maintenance but can enter an order
approving a contractual maintenance agreement between the parties.
With regard to child support, the courts are required to consider
relevant factors associated with the award of child support, which
factors include: (1) the financial resources of the child, (2) the
financial resources of the custodial parent, (3) the standard of
living the child would have enjoyed had the marriage not been
dissolved, (4) the physical and emotional condition of the child and
his or her educational needs, and (5) the financial resources and
needs of the non-custodial parent. Although these items are set
forth by statute for the court's consideration, there is a
chart/table in the Colorado statutes which lists, vertically, the
combined gross income of the two parents, and also sets forth,
horizontally, columns for one, two, three, four, five, and six or
more children. Illustratively, if one has three children, and the
combined income of the two parents is $10,000 per month, the
chart/table would indicate the child support to be allocated between
the two parents is $1,988 per month. If the combined income of the
two spouses exceeds $20,000 gross income per month (the highest
number on the chart/table), the court may award an amount above that
shown on the chart/table for child support. There is no specific
formula or amount of money which the court must award when the
combined gross income exceeds $20,000 per month (the maximum amount
set forth on the aforementioned chart/table).
For purposes of child support guidelines and schedule of basic child
support obligations, there is a Colorado statute which indicates the
type of items included as gross income of each parent so an
appropriate dollar amount can be determined for calculation of child
support. Gross income includes: (1) income from salaries, (2) wages,
including tips declared by the individual for purposes of reporting
to the IRS, (3) commissions, (4) payments received as an independent
contractor for services, (5) bonuses, (6) dividends, (7) severance
pay, (8) pension from retirement benefits, (9) royalties, (10)
rents, (11) interest, (12) trust income, (13) annuities, (14)
capital gains, (15) monies drawn by a self-employed individual for
personal use, (16) social security benefits, (17) workers'
compensation benefits, (18) unemployment insurance benefits, (19)
disability insurance benefits, (20) funds held in, or payable from,
any insurance to the extent the insurance replaces wages, (21)
monetary gifts, (22) monetary prizes, (23) taxable distributions
from business entities, (24) expense reimbursements, (25) alimony or
maintenance received, and (26) overtime pay, only if the overtime is
required by the employer as a condition of employment.
Gross income does not include: (1) child support payments received,
(2) benefits received from public assistance programs, (3) income
from additional jobs which result in the employment of the person
who will pay of more than 40 hours or more per week than what would
otherwise be considered to be full-time employment, and (4) social
security benefits received by minor children, or on their behalf, as
a result of the death or disability of a parent. Where a spouse is
voluntarily unemployed or underemployed, the court has the power to
impute income to that party.
In determining parenting time, the court must take into
consideration the best interests of the child including the wishes
of the parents related to parenting time, and the wishes of the
child if he or she is sufficiently mature to express reasons and
independent preferences as to the parenting time schedule. The court
also takes into consideration the child's adjustment to his or her
home, school, and community, the physical and mental health of all
individuals involved, the ability of the parties to encourage the
sharing of love, affection, and contact between the child and the
other party, whether the past pattern of involvement of the parties
with the child reflects a system of values, time commitment, and
mutual support, the physical proximity of the parties to each other,
whether one of the parties has been a perpetrator of child abuse or
neglect, interaction and interrelationship the child has with his or
her parents, his or her siblings, and any other person who may
significantly affect the child's best interests, and the ability of
each party to place the needs of the child above his or her own
needs.
The court will enter an order indicating which of the spouses, or
both of them, will have certain decision-making authority. The court
may also appoint an individual to evaluate the child and the parents
and make recommendations to the court associated with custody and
decision-making, and may also appoint a guardian for the child to
represent the child's best interests associated with custody and
visitation issues. The court may also appoint a parenting
coordinator or a third-party to assist in the resolution of disputes
between the parties concerning parental responsibilities. The court
also has the legal right to appoint a decision-maker or arbitrator
to resolve disputes or to make appropriate decisions related to the
child.
The judge has the power, after considering the financial resources
of both parties, to order a party to pay a reasonable amount of the
costs to the other party for maintaining or defending any claim or
petition for divorce.
|